Let States Exchange Obamacare For Something Better

Colorado Governor John Hickenlooper established an Obamacare state exchange that is now "teetering," according to a state official. [Credit: mnginteractive.com]

Col­orado Gov­er­nor John Hick­en­loop­er estab­lished an Oba­macare state exchange that is now “tee­ter­ing,” accord­ing to a state offi­cial. [Cred­it: mnginteractive.com]

In the 34 states that did not estab­lish Oba­macare exchanges, Gov­er­nors ner­vous­ly await a Supreme Court rul­ing that could throw their health insur­ance mar­kets into chaos. Mean­while, many of the Gov­er­nors who did estab­lish exchanges are regret­ting their decision.

More than five years after its enact­ment, Oba­macare has proven a bit­ter brew for many states.  Nowhere is this more evi­dent than in health care exchanges. 

Exchanges began as a fig­ment of Washington’s imag­i­na­tion.  The fer­tile minds of health pol­i­cy ana­lysts had con­jured a bewil­der­ing sys­tem of cross-sub­si­dies that involved charg­ing young peo­ple unfair­ly high pre­mi­ums to reduce pre­mi­ums for old­er work­ers, over­charg­ing healthy peo­ple to sub­si­dize unhealthy ones, tax­ing mid­dle income peo­ple to sub­si­dize low­er-income peo­ple (what the Pres­i­dent likes to call “mid­dle class eco­nom­ics”), cut­ting Medicare to enlarge Med­ic­aid, tax­ing the unin­sured for being unin­sured, tax­ing employ­er-spon­sored health plans and tax­ing employ­ers for not spon­sor­ing health plans, all gar­nished with tens of bil­lions in new tax­es on med­i­cines, med­ical “devices” (every­thing from tongue depres­sors to defib­ril­la­tors) and, of course, on health insur­ance itself.

And that was just for starters.  Con­gress also added hun­dreds of bil­lions of dol­lars in pre­mi­um and cost-shar­ing sub­si­dies that fluc­tu­ate with income, cre­at­ing the impos­si­ble admin­is­tra­tive chal­lenge of deter­min­ing who is eli­gi­ble for how much assis­tance and then trans­fer­ring that assis­tance – not to the indi­vid­ual – but to his or her insur­ance com­pa­ny on a month­ly basis.  [A recent Kaiser Fam­i­ly Foun­da­tion study con­clud­ed that the gov­ern­ment last year got the sub­si­dies wrong 95 per­cent of the time, lend­ing new mean­ing to the phrase “close enough for gov­ern­ment work.”]

No enti­ty in cre­ation could admin­is­ter any­thing so baroque.  Thus was the health insur­ance exchange imag­ined into exis­tence.  The notion was that some­thing was need­ed to bring order to these entrop­ic arrange­ments and that, giv­en suf­fi­cient finan­cial induce­ment, states would find a way to make this hal­lu­ci­na­tion real.  So infat­u­at­ed were the law’s archi­tects with their cre­ation that they, along with the ordi­nar­i­ly skep­ti­cal Con­gres­sion­al Bud­get Office, were cer­tain that every state would want one.

Most Gov­er­nors, being a prag­mat­ic lot, saw through the $5 bil­lion bribe that the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment offered up to states to build exchanges.  They told the feds that if exchanges were so won­der­ful, they should set them up themselves.

The few Gov­er­nors who took the bait now find them­selves in a quandary.  The $5 bil­lion hav­ing all been spent, near­ly half of the state-estab­lished exchanges are “strug­gling finan­cial­ly, pre­sent­ing state offi­cials with an unex­pect­ed and seri­ous chal­lenge,” the Wash­ing­ton Post report­ed yesterday.

As with most chal­lenges, gov­ern­men­t’s first impulse is to meet this one with high­er tax­es — in this case, high­er tax­es on insur­ance com­pa­nies.  Such a levy, of course, is no more a tax on insur­ance com­pa­nies than the sales tax is a tax on Tar­get.  Con­sumers pay it; Tar­get mere­ly col­lects it.  Hik­ing the tax on insur­ance com­pa­nies will raise pre­mi­ums, some­thing Gov­er­nors are loathe to do.  So they find them­selves cast­ing about for some way to finance their clunky and error-prone exchanges now that the fed­er­al mon­ey has dried up.

The 34 Gov­er­nors who chose to let the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment run their exchanges are in no posi­tion to gloat.  The leg­isla­tive slap­dash known as Oba­macare makes health insur­ance sub­si­dies avail­able only to con­sumers who pur­chased poli­cies through an exchange “estab­lished by the state” — not through exchanges estab­lished by the fed­er­al government.

The IRS, government’s most pow­er­ful and least account­able agency, laid claim to more pow­er and less account­abil­i­ty by issu­ing a reg­u­la­tion pro­claim­ing that sub­si­dies were to be paid through both fed­er­al and state exchanges, over­rid­ing the law’s plain text.

The Supreme Court is now pon­der­ing whether to legit­imize this IRS audac­i­ty by con­firm­ing the agency’s author­i­ty to write tax law, an author­i­ty hereto­fore reserved to Con­gress.  A Court that often slips its con­sti­tu­tion­al leash in pur­suit of its vision of the greater good will most like­ly save Oba­macare by vin­di­cat­ing the IRS.

But should five jus­tices rule next month that the Con­sti­tu­tion means what it says, 34 Gov­er­nors will find them­selves fac­ing a Sophie’s choice: take on the los­ing propo­si­tion of estab­lish­ing a state exchange or stand by as the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment strips from their res­i­dents sub­si­dies that it had unlaw­ful­ly provided.

Con­gress should give states a third option.

Gov­er­nors and leg­is­la­tures are not Washington’s day labor­ers, con­signed to the dirty work the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment does­n’t care to do.  If Wash­ing­ton wants the states to reform insur­ance mar­kets and dis­pense sub­si­dies, then it should pro­vide states with the resources to imple­ment such a pro­gram and not micro­man­age its administration.

Con­gress should make grants to states for the pur­pose of mak­ing afford­able cov­er­age avail­able to peo­ple with low-incomes and those with pre-exist­ing med­ical con­di­tions.  The grants would be based on the amount that a state’s res­i­dents received in refund­able tax cred­its and cost-shar­ing sub­si­dies under Oba­macare.  All states, includ­ing those that have estab­lished exchanges, would be eli­gi­ble to opt in to the program.

States that chose to receive grants would be relieved of Obamacare’s oppres­sive reg­u­la­to­ry regime of man­dates, exchanges and suf­fo­cat­ing uni­for­mi­ty.  They would regain con­trol over the reg­u­la­tion of health insur­ance and set their own eli­gi­bil­i­ty cri­te­ria for sub­si­dies.  Fed­er­al reg­u­la­tion would be kept to a min­i­mum.  States would be held account­able for results.  The mech­a­nism of achiev­ing those results is a mat­ter for a state to decide, not for the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment to dictate.

To avoid the dis­as­ter that accom­pa­nied the Oba­macare roll­out, states would be giv­en time to put the new pro­gram into place.  Dur­ing this tran­si­tion peri­od, states could, at their option, choose to have the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment con­tin­ue pay­ing sub­si­dies through exist­ing mech­a­nisms until their new sys­tem was ready to launch.

Were Con­gress to enact such a bill, the Pres­i­dent, who makes con­ces­sions only to aya­tol­lahs, would like­ly veto it, then blame Repub­li­can Gov­er­nors and the Repub­li­can Con­gress for the dam­age his veto inflicts.

But unless the 22nd amend­ment is waived, we will have a new Pres­i­dent soon enough.  He or she would do well to treat states as part­ners, rather than ser­vants, in the work of health care reform.